Beyond SOPA: The Past, Present and Future of Internet Censorship

See video
James Corbett
January 29, 2012


Beyond SOPA: The Past, Present and Future of Internet Censorship
by grtv

In recent weeks the general public has mobilized to face US legislative threats to Internet freedoms. Far from a conclusive victory, however, the death of SOPA and PIPA only highlight the latest in a series of measures that are seeking to create a legal framework for government-administered Internet censorship.

Find out more about this contentious topic in this week's GRTV Backgrounder on Global Research TV.


When legislators in the US abandoned their support of SOPA and PIPA in the wake of mass popular protest earlier this month, many of those who had been mobilized by the legislation–which would have granted the US government almost total power to block access to foreign websites accused of so much as linking to copyrighted material–did not have long to enjoy their “victory.” The very next day the New Zealand police swooped in to the million-dollar estate of founder Kim Dotcom, arresting him and three others at the US government’s request for alleged racketeering, copyright infringement and money laundering. The Department of Justice is now seeking the MegaUpload CEO’s extradition to the US.

Some amongst those who had been campaigning against SOPA and PIPA did not know that the US government already had the authority to shut down entire websites and in fact has exercised that authority on numerous occasions. What many are now learning is that, far from some potential future threat, internet censorship already exists in a variety of legislation that is already on the books in the United States and in nations around the world.

Although most commonly associated with China, which has implemented strict internet filters that prevent its citizens from finding politically sensitive material, various internet censorship programs have already been implemented by countries around the globe.

In 2010, Japan passed amendments to its copyright law making it illegal to download copyrighted material. The move has yet to curtail file-sharing in the country, so the Japanese government recently announced that they are going to begin putting fake copies of popular tv dramas on file-sharing websites that, when opened, remind users that it is illegal to download such material.

In July of 2010, the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement seized the domains of 8 websites that it accused of hosting illegal copies of copyrighted material as part of an investigation dubbed Operation In Our Sites. The seizures came before any trial took place, and six of the websites did not actually host any of the copyrighted material in question, only linking to it. That November, ICE acted once again, this time seizing 82 domains. In December of 2011, over one year later, the agency returned one of the domains,, to its owner, after admitting that it had not in fact breached any laws.

In May of last year, the US Justice Department began seeking the extradition of one of the website’s operators, Richard O’Dwyer, from the UK. O’Dwyer is a British citizen who established in December of 2007. The DOJ is hoping to bring O’Dwyer to the US under the Extradition Act of 2003 to face charges of copyright infringement in the Southern District of New York.

Late last year, a number of nations signed a new global copyright agreement known as the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement or ACTA. Signatories include the United States, Canada, Japan, Australia, South Korea, and, as of this past week, 22 member states of the European Union.

Purported to be a treaty against counterfeit goods, generic drugs and copyright, it threatens to fundamentally alter the internet as it has so far existed.

When the Polish government announced its intention to sign earlier this month, protests sprang up around the country.

While the public is only beginning to understand the implications of ACTA, which has already been signed by a number of countries, others are pointing to these types of agreements as only the thin edge of the wedge for the implementation of outright totalitarian control over the internet as a whole. Indeed, perhaps even more worrying than the existing legislation and agreements for internet censorship are the numerous proposals for even more restrictive measures that have been made time and again by political leaders in a variety of contexts.

In October of 2008, the Labor government in Australia proposed a mandatory filter for the entire Australian internet. The proposal, dubbed “Clean Feed” would ostensibly block any content deemed to break Australia’s media regulations. When a list of the websites supposed to be banned under the scheme was released in early 2009, it included the websites of numerous innocuous Australian businesses, as well as overtly political websites that had no illegal or offending material. The current government has said they would not vote for any such legislation, and the proposal would be unlikely to reach parliament until 2013.

In 2010 the UK passed the Digital Economy Act, which theoretically allows for the UK government to ban copyright violators from the Internet. In August of 2011, parts of the legislation proposing the blocking of sites believed to be linking to copyrighted material was declared to be unenforceable and were dropped from the legislation.

In March of 2009, Senator Jay Rockefeller opined during a subcommittee hearing that the internet is proving to be such a threat to America’s national security that it would have been better if it had never existed.

In June of 2010, Senator Joe Lieberman stated that he believed the US needed the same ability to shut down the internet as China currently has.

While these proposals are sometimes couched in business-friendly rhetoric about protecting intellectual property, sometimes as a national security question about defending cyber infrastructure from foreign enemies and sometimes as attempts to protect children or stop the spread of child pornography, the proponents of internet censorship are becoming increasingly honest about their real worry: the free spread of ideas amongst a public that is allowed to choose for themselves what information to believe and what to discard.

Last year, Bill Clinton advocated the idea that the US government create an agency for “fact-checking” websites on the internet.

Earlier this month, Evgeny Morozov of Stanford, who previously served as a Fellow of George Soros’ Open Society Institute, wrote an article calling on Google and other search engines to use banners to warn users about websites that are deemed to be pseudoscientific or conspiratorial. Perhaps realizing that the proposal sounds drastic, Morozov concludes:

“such a move might trigger conspiracy theories of its own—e.g. is Google shilling for Big Pharma or for Al Gore?—but this is a risk worth taking as long as it can help thwart the growth of fringe movements.”

Here we see the real danger of the internet for those who seek to control the spread of information. The internet, like every other medium that has come before it, changes not just the way in which people create, distribute and receive information, but the information itself. Just as the printing press led to the widespread publication of the Bible in the vernacular and ultimately to the Reformation which forever transformed the power structure in European society, so too has the internet allowed the public to receive, correlate and distribute information that challenges official government narratives in a way that threatens to transform the power structure of our society. And as the traditional media has begun to bleed away the remains of its increasingly dissatisfied customer base, self-immolated on the fantastic failure to challenge the status quo on issues like Saddam’s WMD or the growing apparatus of the police state or the never-ending bailouts of the too-big-to-fails, a new, independent media has arisen to take its place, empowered by technologies that allow for the instantaneous and nearly costless transmission of ideas to the farthest corners of the globe.

When situated in this context, the recent struggle over the SOPA and PIPA bills are seen for what they are: one battle in a much larger war for internet freedom, and ultimately, the cognitive liberty of the American public. But it is possible to win the battle and yet lose the war, as the millions of MegaUpload users who just had all of their files seized by the FBI found out the hard way. The only hope is that the movement that has arisen to face this, the greatest threat to the rise of this new era of mental independence, does not wane in the wake of the SOPA and PIPA “victory,” but instead rises to meet the even greater internet clampdown that awaits. After all, all the authorities are waiting for is for the public to fall back asleep.


2012 / 01 / 29
Bob Marshall says:

Yesterday, i received an e-mail from Amazon informing me that i owe my home state, S.C.; state taxes because of a law stating anything i bought through their site, if it was to used used in S.C. was subject to being taxed by the state. They stated that S.C. has had this law in effect since 1953. I wonder how many more states are doing this? Since my state has always been one of the poorest and least educated i am not suprized. I do wonder where our tax money goes since it isn't apparently for education.

2012 / 02 / 01
Mr. Blair M. Phillips says:

No censorship or government ownership!
A number of years ago when I was attending McMaster University as a mature adult part-time student(MAPS) I read an article in a quarterly University publication by a Canadian lawyer who objected to censorship of Holocaust deniers. It was a very good article. Simple, articulate and easy to understand. Found in the conclusions of the article were the reasons for his objections. He felt that education was the key to Holocaust deniers rather than censorship. Being informed is the best way to make educated judgements. Censorship has a slippery slope - remember Galilao and his belief that the world was round and not flat?
The authority on the Nazi Halocaust was Professor Raul Hilberg who was the Chief Prosecuter for the Allies at the Nuremburg Trials. He is also the author of "The Destruction of the European Jews". Read the book and be informed - Holocaust deniers haven't!
No censorship anywhere or any time!

2012 / 02 / 20
Erika says:

We solhud pick a few of? these Senate WHORES and OCCUPY their RESIDENCES! Insider Trading is LEGAL for our so-called representatives ? No F*king WONDER they're so corrupt!!

2012 / 02 / 21
Anonymous says:

The prison camps are ready. The gas chambers were unknown until too late. Quite a few German citizens living near the camps didn't even know the gas chambers existed. Americans will continue to turn a blind eye until it is too late. Wake up, America!

2015 / 09 / 03
sufiya says:

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.
clash of clans | boom beach

2015 / 10 / 11
ahmedraza says:

I should say only that its awesome! The blog is informational and always produce amazing things.
agencia de publicidad guadalajara

2015 / 10 / 11
ahmedraza says:

Effectively, the article is really the best theme on this registry related issue. I fit in with your decisions and will excitedly anticipate your next overhauls.
Garage Door Repair in Boulder

2015 / 10 / 13
gourmet christmas hampers says:

Great post! I am actually getting ready to across this information, is very helpful my friend. Also great blog here with all of the valuable information you have. Keep up the good work you are doing here gourmet christmas hampers

2015 / 10 / 15
debt management tips says:

Your blog provided us with valuable information to work with. Each & every tips of your post are awesome. Thanks a lot for sharing. Keep blogging, debt management tips

2015 / 10 / 17
PioneerSEO says:

A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.

2015 / 10 / 18
pioneerseo says:

I'm hoping you keep writing like this. I love how careful and in depth you go on this topic. Keep up the great work.

2015 / 10 / 18
cost of loft conversion says:

very good now I have to search sites with relevant information on given topic and provide them to teacher our opinion and the article cost of loft conversion

2015 / 10 / 20
alikhan_095 says:

Here We Have Happy New Year 2016 Wishes, Sms, Happy New Year Images 2016, Messages, Quotes, New Year Pictures, Wallpapers and Cards and Much More… New Year Wishes 2016

2015 / 10 / 20
alikhan_095 says:

In this article understand the most important thing, the item will give you a keyword rich link a great useful website page: either acoustically

2015 / 10 / 23
Pioneerseo says:

Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. Thank you for sharing great information to us.

2015 / 10 / 23
alikhan_095 says:

Its as if you had a great grasp on the subject matter, but you forgot to include your readers. Perhaps you should think about this from more than one angle.Mints App Review

2015 / 10 / 23
alikhan_095 says:

Wow! Such an amazing and helpful post this is. I really really love it. It's so good and so awesome. I am just amazed. I hope that you continue to do your work like this in the future also.Dow Jones Focus Group

2015 / 10 / 24
pioneerseo says:

This article is such a nice and interesting one, I'm very satisfied with the provided contents. I hope more excellent articles would be posted in your website. Thank you so much for this and keep

2015 / 10 / 25
Pioneerseo says:

When you really think about it, you’re basically introducing yourself and starting a conversation with another person. That’s it.get a girl to be interested in you

2015 / 10 / 25
ahmedraza says:

dragon city hack online In this particular article, you will see a summary, satisfy browse this post. coc triche

2015 / 10 / 26
peter says:

Wow! Sounds like the interns are having quite a profound experience - and lots of fun too .

2015 / 10 / 27
peter says:

I was attending McMaster University as a mature adult part-time student(MAPS) I read an article in a quarterly . USA Instagram followers

2015 / 10 / 27
peter says:

Wow! Sounds like the interns are having quite a profound experience - and lots of fun too! cheap essay writers

2015 / 10 / 27
peter says:

my daughter's preschool "Thanksgiving" feast, was too late bringing a whole bottle of ketchup (that I had to go to the store . cloud image hosting

2015 / 10 / 27
ismailkhan1 says:

A very awesome blog post. We are really grateful for your blog post. You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post.cccam server

2015 / 10 / 27
peter says:

Writing only comments will close the discussion straight away! And will restrict the benefits from this information account doubling app

2015 / 10 / 28
peter says:

Yesterday, i received an e-mail from Amazon informing me that i owe my home state,

2015 / 10 / 28
alikhan_095 says:

Hi there, I discovered your blog per Google bit searching for such kinda educational advise moreover your inform beholds very remarkable for me. The Salvation Diet System

2015 / 10 / 29
peter says:

I was just browsing through the internet looking for some information and came across your blog. I am
cleaning services westchase fl
impressed by the information that you have on this blog.

2015 / 10 / 29
AsharSeo says:

You have done a great job. I will definitely dig it and personally recommend to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.. Adventskranz 2015

2015 / 10 / 29
AsharSeo says:

I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains wonderful and helpful posts. Keep up the good work!

2015 / 10 / 29
peter says:

We solhud pick a few of? these Senate WHORES and OCCUPY their RESIDENCES! Insider Trading is LEGAL for our so-called representatives . go

2015 / 12 / 03
anuskhan says:

We solhud pick a few of? these Senate WHORES and OCCUPY their RESIDENCES....
seo service

2016 / 01 / 02
asefrg says:

I have bookmarked it and I am looking forward to reading new articles.
my profile,
click here

2016 / 01 / 17
pioneerseo says:

The best ceramic cookware is becoming increasingly popular because, unlike metal cookware and cookware treated with non-stick coatings, it is completely unreactive with the food being cooked in nonstick ceramic cookware

2016 / 02 / 01
emmajacker says:

I enjoyed in this article. Thank you for sharing.

double down casino promo codes

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.
By submitting this form, you accept the Mollom privacy policy.

Related videos

Our newsletter